What are Jobless Claims?
Jobless claims, reported weekly by the U.S. Department of Labor, measure the number of people who filed for unemployment benefits.
- Jobless claims measure the number of people who filed for unemployment benefits.
- There are two types of jobless claims: (1) Initial claims and (2) Continued claims.
- In general, financial markets tend to react positively when jobless claims are lower than expected.
Understanding Jobless Claims
There are two types of jobless claims:
- Initial Claims: The number of people that have filed for unemployment benefits for the first time.
- Continued Claims: The number of unemployed people who have already been receiving unemployment benefits.
Of the two types of jobless claims, the initial claims reading is considered of greater importance and is regarded as a leading economic indicator (meaning there is a predictive power of the reading on future economic conditions). It is because there tends to be a negative relationship between initial claims and the employment rate – as initial claims decline/increase, the employment rate tends to increase/decline.
A rising/declining employment rate can signal greater/lower disposable income, leading to higher/lower consumption, resulting in the belief of a strong/weak economy. Furthermore, the fact that the jobless claims figure is published weekly lends itself as a favorable leading economic indicator to use by analysts and economists.
How Jobless Claims Impact the Financial Markets
The jobless claims reading is commonly compared to consensus estimates, of which material deviations can generate a market reaction.
Confusion may arise from whether a better-than-expected jobless claims reading refers to a higher or lower actual reading versus expected:
- A better-than-expected jobless claims reading (referred to as a “beat”) means a lower reading than consensus; while
- A worse-than-expected jobless claims reading (referred to as a “miss”) means a higher reading than the consensus.
The market reaction to the jobless claims reading depends on the current business cycle and monetary/fiscal policy expectations. In general, the market reaction tends to be positive when jobless claims are lower than expected.
For example, in September 2021, initial jobless claims were 340,000 for the week versus a consensus of 345,000, prompting optimism regarding the U.S. labor market. As a result, markets reacted positively, with the S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite climbing to new respective records.
Methodology of Jobless Claims
Recall that jobless claims measure the number of people who filed for unemployment benefits. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, to generally qualify for unemployment benefits, the individual must:
- Be unemployed through no fault of their own, and
- Meet specific state requirements on work and wage requirements, etc. They can be found here.
It is important to note that there is potential for the jobless claims reading to point to an incorrect inference on the state of the labor market. It is because numerous types of people are excluded from the reading, such as:
- Individuals who are self-employed
- Unpaid workers
- Unemployed workers who no longer receive benefits
- Individuals who are unemployed but do not meet state benefits requirements
As an extreme example, there may be a low jobless claims reading coupled with a low employment rate if workers have been claiming unemployment benefits for so long that they run out of benefits to claim. In such a case, a low jobless claims reading may indicate a healthy labor market, when in fact the labor market may be under extreme distress as workers struggle to find work over an extended period of time.
It is important to use other leading economic indicators in conjunction with the jobless claims reading when seeking to predict the outlook of the economy.
Initial Jobless Claims as a Leading Indicator
As mentioned, initial jobless claims are considered a leading economic indicator. In fact, the initial jobless claims reading form one of the ten components of The Conference Board’s Composite Index of Leading Indicators, outlined below:
In order to help you become a world-class financial analyst and advance your career to your fullest potential, these additional resources will be very helpful: