What is Normative Economics?
Normative economics is a school of thought which believes that economics as a subject should pass value statements, judgments and opinions on economic policies, statements, and projects. It evaluates situations and outcomes of economic behavior and evaluates them as good or bad.
Normative economics, as opposed to positive economics, tells us whether certain aspects of the economy are helpful or harmful. These statements are subject to the opinions of the people making the statements and are often without any basis or facts.
Examples of Normative Economics
- The regulation of the oil prices by the government helps to keep inflation in check.
- The independence of the central bank from the government should be curtailed.
- The development of Special Economic Zones is not working out.
- Progressive taxation is better than regressive taxation.
- Companies should be made to pay for the pollution they cause.
All of the above statements are subjective. They represent nothing more than an individual’s opinion on how the economy should be. Economists are often guided by their personal value systems while making these statements and hence, all are subjective in nature. Welfare economist and Nobel laureate Amartya Sen distinguishes normative statements in two parts. According to him, basic statements do not depend on any knowledge of facts or theories, whereas non-basic statements depend on the facts or knowledge of facts.
Origin of Normative Economics
Normative economics first originated from “old-style welfare economics,” which is a simplified version of Pigou’s Economics of Welfare. “New welfare economics” came as the second form of normative economics in the 1930s. It was clearer than the previous form with respect to its assumptions. It used the Pareto Principle and the Compensation Principle to make normative statements about policies and state whether they were improving welfare or not. The latest form of normative economics is social choice theory and public economics. Public economics studies the effects of the public sector on society and the economy as a whole. The social choice theory uses the method of voting to aggregate individual choices to indicate social preferences.
Prominent Normative Economists
- Adam Smith – He was a Scottish economist, philosopher, and author in the 18th century. He is well known for two of his publications – The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and An Inquiry into the Nature and causes of the Wealth of Nations. In The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Smith states sympathy as the initiation of action in society. His arguments about moral sentiments and sympathy as the foundation of rules and justice paved the way for modern normative economics.
2. Amartya Sen – Amartya Sen is a 20th-century Indian economist and a Nobel laureate. He tries to discuss the distinction between positive and normative economics in his book “Economic Behavior and Moral Sentiments.” He emphasizes the fact that since welfare economics have a significant impact on actual behavior, ethical considerations should have a greater role in welfare economics, which according to him, have been largely ignored.
Normative Economics vs. Positive Economics
Positive economics, on the other hand, concerns itself with only stating facts and figures. It does not pass any judgment on any economic policy or economic behavior. The major difference between positive economics and normative economics is that the statements made by positive economics can be tested for their validity. They may either be true or false but can always be tested. Conversely, judgments passed by normative statements cannot be tested for their validity because of their subjectivity.
For example, let us consider a positive statement, “The unemployment rate prevailing in the economy currently is 8%.” We know that there are measures to test whether this statement is true or not. Together with positive statements, normative statements help policymakers and leaders to reach opinion-based solutions to prevailing economic issues. Hence, both positive and normative economics play a vital role in the functioning of an economy.