English Auction

Open cry ascending auction

What is an English Auction?

An English Auction, also referred to as an open cry ascending auction, starts by an auctioneer announcing the suggested opening bid or reserve price for the item on sale. The buyers with interest in the item start placing bids on the item on sale, with the auctioneer accepting higher bids as they come.

The buyer with the highest bid at any time is considered the one with a standing bid, which can only be displaced by a higher bid from the floor. If there are no higher bids than the standing bid, the auctioneer announces the winner, and the item is sold to the person with the standing bid at a price equal to their bid. If the reserve price is not met or no buyer places an economically fair bid, the seller can take the item off the market.

 

English Auction Process

 

One of the unique features of an English auction is that the bidders are aware of the prices and the numbers of other bidders. At the opening of the auction, the auctioneer discloses the identity of the other bidders and the reserve price is set by the seller. The bids start at a low price and ascend up to a point when there are no more bids. A bidder not only observes the valuations of other people but also gets an opportunity to revise his valuation beyond the previous bids. If there is only one item for sale and each of the buyers places an independent private value on the item, the expected payments and revenue from the auction are theoretically equal to the Vickrey auction. A Vickrey auction is a sealed-bid auction, where each of the bidders submits a written bid, the amount of which is unknown to all the other bidders.

 

English Auction

 

Variations of English Auctions

There are several variations of the English auction. The most common variation is the English Clock Auction where the auction starts from a low price and begins to rise gradually with each bid placed by the prospective buyers. If a buyer wants to drop out of the auction, he must signal the auctioneer. A buyer who has dropped out of the bidding cannot be allowed to come back in and resume bidding. The auction ends when only one bidder is remaining, and the auctioneer announces the winner. The winning buyer pays a price equal to their current bid price.

The other variation of the English auction is the time-interval auction, which is common in real estate and manuscript auctions. In a time-interval auction, the bidding may take several days or weeks but must be completed within a specified allotted period of time. One example is the eBay auction. Once a product’s been placed for sale on eBay, buyers are allowed a specific time frame within which to place their bid. The buyer with the highest bid at the close of the bidding becomes the winner and takes possession of the item after paying their current bid price. Most buyers wait until very near the end of the auction time to place a relatively high bid, in hope that no other bidder will outbid them in the limited time remaining before the auction closes.

 

English Auction Bidding Strategies

Bidders in an English auction may use the following strategies to outdo their competitors:

1. Bid Jumping

Bid jumping involves placing a bid that is above the next bid increment. The bid may jump to a price point high enough to discourage other bidders from continuing with the bidding. For example, if the bid price is proceeding from $100 to $120 to $150, the bidder may place a bid of $500. The advantage of this strategy is that the other bidders may drop out of the bidding process after being discouraged by the sudden increase in price or sensing defeat, leaving only the bid jumper. However, the bid jumper must consider the possibility that they may have have paid an unnecessarily higher price in order to chase out the other bidders. In this example, the bidder may have been able to win the auction at a price of, say, $300, had they followed a normal bidding progression rather than using a jump bidding strategy.

2. Lighthouse Bidding

A lighthouse bidding strategy occurs when a bidder lifts his paddle up in the air and leaves it there, signaling that he is prepared to increase his bid indefinitely in order to win the auction.  This is another strategy designed to discourage other bidders from continuing to bid any further, because they expect the lighthouse bidder to outbid them regardless of how high a bid they make. A lighthouse bidding strategy, even though it effectively signals the bidder’s willingness to “pay any price necessary”, may actually enable him to win the auction at a lower price than he would have otherwise. For example, a bidder who may have originally been willing to bid as high as $200 may drop out of the bidding at a lower price level because he believes the lighthouse bidder will outbid him no matter how much he bids. The risk of the lighthouse bidding strategy is that a rival bidder may bid up the price to a point much higher than he is actually willing to pay, just to make the the lighthouse bidder pay a very high price to win the auction.

3. Cutting the Bid

Cutting the bid means placing a bid that is less than the amount that the bidding has been proceeding with. For example, if the bid has been progressing from $100 to $150 to $200, a buyer may want to bid at $180. For this to happen, the buyer must signal the auctioneer to make his intentions known. When cutting the bid by half, the common signal is to raise the arm and hold one hand horizontally to the next with the palm facing downwards. If the auctioneer gives the go-ahead for the bid price, the buyer announces the $180 bid price and waits to see if there is a higher bid.

4. Head Nod/Head Shake

Head nods or shakes are used to communicate to the auctioneer a bidder’s willingness to continue bidding. If an auctioneer looks at a buyer and the buyer nods his head, it means that he is still in the bidding. However, if a buyer shakes his head, it means that they are withdrawing from the bidding.

 

Other Types of Auctions

 

1. Swedish Auction

In a Swedish auction, the seller of the item up for auction is free to accept or decline any bids by a buyer. It is less regulated, and the bidders are not bound by the bids they put forward. The auction originated from the Swedish real estate market.

2. Dutch Auction

A Dutch auction is a type of price discovery process.  The process works by an auctioneer beginning with the highest asking price and then continuously lowering it until all the bids received will cover the quantity offered (for sale). A Dutch auction can also be referred to as a descending price auction.  This type of auction can be used in an Initial Public Offering (IPO) and is also used by governments for the pricing of financial instruments such as Treasury billsnotes, and bonds.

3. Candle Auction

A candle auction is an auction whose termination is signaled by the expiration of a candle flame. It ensures that no bidder knows the exact time the auction will end so that they can make a final winning bid. Of course, bidders in candle auctions try their best to anticipate when the candle flame will expire, aiming to enter the highest bid just before then, leaving other bidders no time to outbid them.

4. Japanese Auction

Unlike an English auction where the price changes according to the bidders’ outcries, the bid price in a Japanese auction changes according to the auctioneer’s clock. Bidders only have the right to decide if and when to drop out of the bidding.

 

Other Resources

CFI is a global provider of financial modeling courses and financial analyst certification.  To continue developing your career in the financial services industry, theses additional resources will be helpful:

Financial Analyst Training

Get world-class financial training with CFI's online certified financial analyst training program! Gain the confidence you need to move up the ladder in a high powered corporate finance career path.  

Learn financial modeling and valuation in Excel the easy way, with step-by-step training.